PDA

View Full Version : Latest news on power plant


patw
09-22-2010, 05:41 PM
BEC chairman: Full steam ahead on Wilson City power plant
9/21/2010
LEDEDRA MARCHE
Senior FN Reporter
lededra@nasguard.com
Now that the Supreme Court has dismissed the judicial action against the Bahamas Electricity Corporation's multi-million dollar Wilson City power plant, the corporation's chairman Michael Moss said yesterday work on the project is moving full steam ahead.
"We are elated with the ruling that has been handed down,"he toldThe Nassau Guardian.
"In terms of the way forward, we are continuing with the work at Wilson City and we are hoping to have a formal takeover of the power plant certainly by not later than mid to late November."
Responsible Development for Abaco(RDA)filed a suit in Grand Bahama against the prime minister, the ministers of the environment, health and public works and transport, the South Abaco District Council, and the attorney general in December 2009 regarding the$105 million power plant in Wilson City, Abaco.
The group had claimed residents were not consulted and permits obtained back in October of 2009 were done so in secret.
Government signed the contract in December 2007.
RDA had also applied for an injunction to stay any further work, but, up to that point, was denied.
The group had maintained that the move was an attempt by the residents to get the government to recognize and acknowledge that residents should have a say and a right to be consulted in all of the permit applications being made to the relevant authorities.
All sides initially met before Justice Hartman Longley in April of this year for what was to be the start of the judicial review, but at that time had been given time to find common ground.
Justice Longley ruled last week that the group should have brought the judicial review proceedings sooner, at least by June of 2008 or November 2008 at the latest.
"In the circumstances, the applicants had until six months after the date of the signing of the contract to bring their application or risk being put out of court for being too late. It is common ground that they did not do so within that timeframe,"the judge ruled.
Justice Longley also found on the evidence that the applicants had knowledge of the decision to build the plant and did not bring the application until more than 18 months later when construction had already commenced.
Also, finding that the applicants offered no good reason to extend the time, Justice Longley revealed that he was dismissing the application on the grounds of delay.
"In the circumstances, there is no good reason offered to extend the time. I would therefore dismiss the application for the judicial review on the basis of delay,"the judge ruled.
Yesterday, Moss said one of the engines at the plant has been run up to full load.
Two of the engines have been run up to three quarters of their load and a fourth engine is yet to be run, he said.
"We anticipate that the fourth engine will be run for the first time sometime within the next week,"he said.
"Once all four engines have been run and checked out at full load, then the units will be subjected to what can best be described as a stress test."
Moss explained that will involve running each of the engines at actual load for a 30-day period to ensure they are capable of continuously running at maximum load if called upon to do so.
According to Moss, the plant should have been operation several months ago.
"We're not back on track, but certainly it feels good to have that gray cloud removed from over our heads and feeling comfortable that we can now complete this project and get it put behind us,"he said.
RDA attorney Fred Smith noted previously that the main thrust of the case was to ensure that the power plant was built in an environmentally safe manner that did not threaten the water table, the blue holes and the unique system of underwater caverns which help ensure Abaco's clean drinking water.
The Nassau Guardianwas unable to reach Smith for comment yesterday as he was said to be out of the country.
In his ruling, however, Justice Longley noted that RDA had drawn attention to the fact that the construction was going ahead without the necessary permits and the fact that many procedures were ignored or bypassed.
"In one instance,"Justice Longley pointed out,"a stop work order had to be issued so that the proper permits could be obtained."
Justice Longley also opined that RDA's role was"very constructive"and that their participation should be welcomed by the respondents, and cause a review of the protocols for the future when projects like the Wilson City power plant are put on the drawing board.
"There is no question that had they not highlighted the fact that necessary permits were not obtained which probably brought embarrassment to the respondents, the project might have been moving along in the words of Mr. Smith as a runaway train. Even now the project is proceeding with conditional approvals in some cases,"he ruled.

SamFamAustin
09-22-2010, 07:35 PM
Justice Longley also opined that RDA's role was"very constructive"and that their participation should be welcomed by the respondents, and cause a review of the protocols for the future when projects like the Wilson City power plant are put on the drawing board.

Well that's a good sign! Maybe the Bahamas needs a environmental impact statement process in the future for projects like Baker's, Wilson, and whatever else comes along. Thanks PatW for the article.

Blue Moon Cottage
09-23-2010, 09:55 AM
But what work has been done on the infrastructure.. Will the old frayed, small cords cables and lines handle the power? I do not hink so! I also have not seen or heard of improvements being done to them.
Anyone know? If that is not addressed all the power in the world will not get to us!

SamFamAustin
09-23-2010, 12:02 PM
Onviously I am no engineer, but the idea is to get all that juice to the Marsh Harbour Substation without blowing it up. :eek:

From that point, the loads to the various distribution lines and various cays should be about the same as it has been.

So if there's any activity, it would be on the road between Wilson City and Marsh Harbour, some brand new, shiny aluminum wires on fairly large telephone poles.

The last semi-official report I heard was that was sufficient line capacity to test one generator at full load.
-sammie

gazeboman
09-23-2010, 05:14 PM
But what work has been done on the infrastructure.. Will the old frayed, small cords cables and lines handle the power? I do not hink so! I also have not seen or heard of improvements being done to them.
Anyone know? If that is not addressed all the power in the world will not get to us!

Maybe if we all donate our old used extension cords??:cool::cool::cool:

boatbum
09-23-2010, 05:15 PM
Having read this I feel much better about spending the Winter in the Abacos again. Last year we arrived just after the fire, and while power was out once in a while, it was bearable. Probably nothing like Summer given the extra load of refrigeration.

:D

Blue Moon Cottage
09-24-2010, 09:30 AM
power and phones out most of yesterday and hardly any people actually on any cays.. what can the reason be now?

Two Turtles
09-24-2010, 09:42 AM
Maybe saving it for the busy days:confused:

patw
09-24-2010, 09:59 AM
Guana had power but we didn't have phones until late in the afternoon.


power and phones out most of yesterday and hardly any people actually on any cays.. what can the reason be now?

Blue Moon Cottage
09-25-2010, 09:28 AM
and still I question no improvements to the infrastructure.

boatbum
09-25-2010, 10:00 AM
Infrastructure will do no good without something driving it, and that includes new switch gear on the supply side.

Blue Moon Cottage
09-25-2010, 07:52 PM
Infrastructure will do no good without something driving it, and that includes new switch gear on the supply side.

which to me is _____ INFRASTRUCTURE!!!!! if the plant does actually function, produce enough power for all... It must be able to get to us.

boatbum
09-25-2010, 08:00 PM
Granted the infrastructure to the out islands might be a bit weak. But then, think about the costs involved and add to that the notion that there are all these boaters out there ignorant of charts that throw a hook and rip the lines up. I've seen it happen on the Hudson river.
The out islands, or Cays are a very difficult environment to distribute power to.

SamFamAustin
09-26-2010, 12:37 PM
Very true, Dan, and anything by the coast is quite a "sticky wicket." After Hurricane Ike hit Houston in 2008, the entire electrical infrastructure was crippled in an urban area of about 4 million people, thus calling for the utilities to "harden" their distribution poles.

The utilities responded that they are steadily funding for tree removal and equipment upgrades, but that such a project would cost billions of dollars. The utilities couldn't afford doing all that at once, so therefore the rate payers would have to foot the bill - which could roughly double electric bills. Forever.

Under this plan, all trees within 30 feet would be taken out, not just trimmed. People howled in protest, since many of these large trees had been shade-makers for generations.

In the end the utilities won, as you would expect. "Coastal hardening" was put off for continued maintenance.

Now let's consider those submarine cables which transverse the bays and sounds from Marsh Harbour to the cays. Brand new, state-of-the-art cabling buried 2 feet and backfilled with sand and gravel costs about a million dollars a mile. That is why the existing cables must be patched and repaired as best as possible, given the rash of anchor dragging and natural aging. You really can't trench much of the cable because of the sensitive corals and hard limestone, unlike the sandy muds found elsewhere up along the East Coast.

Can you imaging the protests if BEC was caught with giant trenching equipment, excavators, dredges, and dynamite to lay cable across the reefs?

So it's a game of always being behind and playing catch-up. The only thing good about an occasional bad storm is that it usually takes out the weakest links, such as the rotten telephone poles, the older transformers ready to fritz, and the larger trees in decline that fall onto the wires. -sam

180degrees
09-26-2010, 02:00 PM
This is a very good point. Please advise which official government chart has the cable crossing marked. And, in defense of us ignorant boaters, I don't remember ever seeing any signage along the shore about cables.

Has it ever been considered to have smaller power plants on each cay to reduce the reach of a centralized problem?

SamFamAustin
09-26-2010, 02:40 PM
This is a very good point. Please advise which official government chart has the cable crossing marked. And, in defense of us ignorant boaters, I don't remember ever seeing any signage along the shore about cables.

Has it ever been considered to have smaller power plants on each cay to reduce the reach of a centralized problem?

Good comments. I really haven't seen any charts that show cable crossings - you'd think maybe that NOAA, Dodge, and the Bahamian government would want to identify those with squiggely lines and a "No Anchoring" notice to mariners. No signs, no buoys, no maps, I can see your point.

The issue with BEC is that aside from some small-scale providers and Freeport Electric (whatever it is called), and some self-styled independents who make their own power at their own cost, the BEC is all about centralization. That's why they put four 12-megawatt generators of Marsh Harbour instead of having distributed power on each cay.

You're not going to believe this but don't shoot the messenger - BEC put "all its eggs in one basket" for the Abacos because it's supposed to be cheaper! :eek:

OK, I'm not a very good comedian.

boatbum
09-26-2010, 05:03 PM
I have electronic charts from Nobeltec (somewhat dated) and the just about latest raster charts.
I will admit they are not all that well charted. I see a few lines charted. One to GTC and perhaps one to Elbow but that's about it. The chartography should be updated for sure, but it would seem no one is interested in getting this taken care of at BTC. Maybe they are able to get the money out of their insurance company for maintenance :D

Actually Sam having it centralized is probably cheaper considering staffing, maintenance and fuel logistics etc...

anchor out
09-26-2010, 06:28 PM
I have electronic charts from Nobeltec (somewhat dated) and the just about latest raster charts.
I will admit they are not all that well charted. I see a few lines charted. One to GTC and perhaps one to Elbow but that's about it. The chartography should be updated for sure, but it would seem no one is interested in getting this taken care of at BTC. Maybe they are able to get the money out of their insurance company for maintenance :D

Actually Sam having it centralized is probably cheaper considering staffing, maintenance and fuel logistics etc...


As recently as 3 or 4 years ago I remember seeing a sign at Tahiti Beach warning boaters not to anchor due to an underwater power cable. I think it ran to Lubbers but don't know that for certain. I did get in the water and the cable was there but I think it was inoperative (at that time).

Maybe the Bloombox will change all this. One for every cay, or hey... one for every property! I, for one, am looking forward to the development of this story.
Ken

Tingum
09-27-2010, 04:27 PM
Anyone have an update on the generator? Abaconian said one on line in September at partial capacity.

patw
09-27-2010, 04:44 PM
The power has been crazy all day here on Guana. I spoke with my sister in-law and she said its been up and down in MH today too. Its gone out three times here and the last time it surged really bad! I can only hope that BEC is working on the generator and maybe, that's why the power is going up and down.

South Pause
09-29-2010, 08:47 AM
Pat: Did the power ever "settle down" since Monday?

patw
09-29-2010, 09:18 AM
Yes, BUT we haven't had power since about 6 am this morning. I THINK its because we had some thunderstorms and winds gusts. Its raining here and very gusty winds at times.

Pat: Did the power ever "settle down" since Monday?